Shop

Showing 1–12 of 95 results

12 products per page24 products per page48 products per page96 products per page

Default sorting Sort by popularity Sort by average rating Sort by newness Sort by price: low to high Sort by price: high to low

• 

  Regular Assorted Taffy (18)

• 

  Sugar-Free Assorted Taffy (5)

• 

  1lb Assorted Regular Taffy

  $10.45
• 

  1lb Assorted Sugar-Free Taffy

  $11.45
• 

  1lb Vanilla Peanut Butter

  $10.95
• 

  4oz Assorted Regular Taffy

  $4.25
• 

  4oz Assorted Sugar-Free Taffy

  $5.25
• 

  4oz Chocolate Peanut Butter

  $4.95
• 

  4oz Molasses Peanut Butter

  $4.95
• 

  4oz Sassy Taffy Assorted

  $4.25
• 

  4oz Sea Salt Vanilla Caramels

  $4.95
• 

  4oz Vanilla Peanut Butter

  $4.95
• 

  4oz Vanilla Peanut Butter Sugar-Free Taffy

  $5.95
• 

  8oz Assorted Regular Taffy

  $6.25

12 products per page24 products per page48 products per page96 products per page